Print Page | Close Window

rims tires compared to stock tires

Printed From: the12volt.com
Forum Name: General Discussion
Forum Discription: General Mobile Electronics Questions and Answers
URL: https://www.the12volt.com/installbay/forum_posts.asp?tid=40184
Printed Date: June 02, 2024 at 9:07 PM


Topic: rims tires compared to stock tires

Posted By: AJRXtreme
Subject: rims tires compared to stock tires
Date Posted: October 02, 2004 at 11:18 PM

alright i have stock rims right now with really good tires. Ive been able to go 75,000 miles before they had to be replaced. I wanted to know if i could do the same with tires for 22 inch rims. My dad says if u get tires for 22's then u will probably only be able to go 25,000 miles before they have to be replaced. Also i heard that u arent able to align the wheels if u have rims, because if the wheels arent aligned they wear a lot easier. If anyone could give me any advice please do so. Thankyou

-------------
03 F150 on 24's
HU:Pioneer DVD5700
Frt:MC57
Subs:(12)S12L7
Amps:(3)KX2500.1's, MC-2004



Replies:

Posted By: NowYaKnow
Date Posted: October 03, 2004 at 1:04 AM
"alright i have stock rims right now with really good tires. Ive been able to go 75,000 miles before they had to be replaced. I wanted to know if i could do the same with tires for 22 inch rims."

Very doubtful, but I guess it depends on your driving habits. Even 25,000 would be a stretch in my opinion.

"Also i heard that u arent able to align the wheels if u have rims"

There's no reason why you can't align the wheels..

Also if you plan to get wheels that large, make sure you upgrade your brakes!

Mike




Posted By: AJRXtreme
Date Posted: October 03, 2004 at 1:19 PM
Instead of aligning the wheels i meant balancing the wheels. I heard u arent able to balance the wheels when u have 22 inch rims. I also wanted to know why u have to upgrade your brakes. Thankyou in advance.

-------------
03 F150 on 24's
HU:Pioneer DVD5700
Frt:MC57
Subs:(12)S12L7
Amps:(3)KX2500.1's, MC-2004




Posted By: flynntech
Date Posted: October 03, 2004 at 10:45 PM

to take advantage of that extra contact surface!

Seriously, why go half way? Go full circle and build a real car.





Posted By: boxmaker85
Date Posted: October 04, 2004 at 1:12 PM

There shouldn't be a problem w/ balancing the tires.  Might be more dificult for the tire place and they might charge you more but they should be able to do it.  And yeah NowYaKnow probably right w/ the brakes.  Upgrade them.  It's a kinda complicated physics explination of eqations.  Also it lookes kinda retarded if you have huge rims and little dinky stock disk/drum breaks inside that are like 1/4 the size of the rims.





Posted By: Ravendarat
Date Posted: October 04, 2004 at 7:09 PM
The brake thing is easy, a larger wheel has more forward momentum and a larger contact surface making it harder to stop, if you dont upgrade your brakes than your braking distance will be extended and your brake life will go down the tubes. Also for what its worth I have a customer that has 22 inch spinners on his caddy and he has like 45000 km on his tires right now and they are still perfectly fine so I think you can still get long life as long as you dont drive like a retard and buy good tires to start with.

-------------
double-secret reverse-osmosis speaker-cone-induced high-level interference distortion, Its a killer




Posted By: boxmaker85
Date Posted: October 04, 2004 at 10:46 PM

Actually a larger contact surface would mean easier braking b/c there is more area of the nonmoving group of particles trying to resist motion compared to a smaller tire w/ less contact surface, therefore less area for the nonmoving object to grip. 

But let's say you have ABS.  Then bravo to Ravendarat.  The 22" has more mass then the stock (let's say 16").  And a 22" rim has a greater rotational velocity at it's edge.  Greater mass, greater velocity all equal a greater momentum.  Greater momentum means you need a greater force counteracting the momentum (a bigger brake).  Gotta love physics and dynamics.





Posted By: flynntech
Date Posted: October 04, 2004 at 11:01 PM

I was just thinking about this today...

larger rims don't always wiegh much more than stock rims. Some can be very light, I'm assuming these rims are lightwieght, otherwise what's the point?

The problem most likely comes form the majority of the wieght being further away from the center, having stronger momentum against the brakes. I'm no physics expert, but I relate this to using a breaker bar over a stubby wrench, which is easier to turn?

A few good reasons to upgrade the brakes, most have been mentioned:

1. Don't expose weakness......showing off stock drums and rotors with large rims is uncool....it looks like you spent all of your money on rims and ran out of steam. It also looks like the car is trying to be something it can't be, because it can't.

2. Stock brakes suck anyways....at least upgrade the pads and hoses (steel braid)

3. the rims will be harder on the brakes, enter formulas for rotational force here:

I have a whole book of this from NEMA, it's an engineering pocket book, it's fascinating!

4. These tires will have better hanfling, braking and handling go hand in hand...otherwise there is an unbalance in performance.

5. Safety, don't you want to know your car will stop when and where you want it to stop?

Just think, if you encountered a deer, multi car pile-up at 70 mph, stupid drivers, drunk drivers running red lights...ect.. would you be able to stop?

6. Deceleration can be just as much fun as acceleration......once and a while :D





Posted By: boxmaker85
Date Posted: October 05, 2004 at 11:29 AM
Did a problem like this today in class.  The mass of a rotating object concentrates at the center of rotation.  Mass will still probably be slightly more than stock though, so momentum will increase ever-so-slightly.  Breaking w/ a larger wheel comapred to a smaller wheel (assuming all other factors are the same and the two have about the same mass) both will have approx. the same distance.  But upgrade for cosmetic reasons.  flynntech's got the idea with this.




Posted By: Asmodeus
Date Posted: October 05, 2004 at 11:18 PM

Came here to talk car audio got a physics lesson.

But they are right...( A little math for you) Big Rims +  Small brakes = No stopping power...



-------------
posted_image
Making the World A Louder Place




Posted By: Mad Scientists
Date Posted: October 06, 2004 at 7:16 AM

Lower profile tires tend to have softer tread compound.. meaning they 'stick' better to the road. They also wear out faster. Look at the wear rating on the tire.. The Michelins Harmonys we have on a couple of our cars have a rating of 560. A Michelin Pilot in the same size may have a rating of only 180. The higher the number the longer the tire will last. www.tirerack.com should have a pretty good article on this.. look for 'tire ratings'.

 Balancing a large diameter rim isn't really any different than a 'normal' sized one.. the ability of a shop to balance (and mount) any particular rim size will be determined by what equipment they use.  Same for alignment.. shop equipment might not be able to handle a 22" rim, just put the stock rims back on the car for the alignment, then put the big rims back on. Shouldn't be any problems.

 WRT brakes.. when changing rim or tire size, consider the Outside Diameter of the tire.. this determines the revolutions per mile of the tire. A tire sized 205/55-16 has the same OD (and RPM) of a tire sized 185/75-14.  The car won't know the difference. But when you start increasing the OD of the tire over the stock size you start seeing problems with speedometer inaccuracy, possible ABS problems and acceleration problems, as well as possible problems in other areas.

 But in a quick google search, I'm not seeing any warnings on big rims causing brake problems.. about the only thing I can think of is that a larger OD would cause a slower rotor RPM at any given speed vs. stock tire OD, but I don't know if that would cause problems. Weight wouldn't really be a concern WRT braking; that's more of a suspension issue.

 If anyone can post links to warnings/tech articles, I'd be happy to learn..

 Hope this helps,

 Jim





Posted By: AJRXtreme
Date Posted: October 07, 2004 at 3:48 AM
how would I upgrade the brakes. Meaning what part of the brakes should i replace on my old ones.
               Thankyou

-------------
03 F150 on 24's
HU:Pioneer DVD5700
Frt:MC57
Subs:(12)S12L7
Amps:(3)KX2500.1's, MC-2004




Posted By: sk8ingsmurf
Date Posted: October 07, 2004 at 8:17 AM
you would generally just upgrade the rotors (hopefully you have them, if not then just the drums), and while you have the assembly apart change out the pads too.  If the urge struck you you could upgrade the brake likes and possibly even master cylinder, but for this application I see no need.  I would highly recommend cross drilled or slotted rotors (slotted work better but the slots chew apart pads), I am currently driving a 99 expedition with cross drilled rotors and ceramic pads, they cost a litte more but I gotta tell you that in my car you get a lot more done stepping on the brake than the gas.  Gotta love suvs




Posted By: Mad Scientists
Date Posted: October 07, 2004 at 10:03 AM

From a performace standpoint, upgrading (disc) brakes would start with a better quality brake pad; maybe a upgraded rotor in the same size as the OEM brake rotor. That'll cover 90 something percent of the people out there driving on the street. For the few people who need better brakes because what they've got isn't getting the job done (driving serious on a track), you start looking at multi piston calipers and bigger rotors - ie. a 'big brake' setup.

 To fill up a set of big rims,  jump directly to a set of 'big brakes'. Bring your wallet. Bigger diameter rotors, new calipers painted shiny with someone's name on them, new pads, and possibly other stuff.

 Here's a kit for 7th generation Civics..

https://www.7thgencivic.com/parts_reviews/showproduct.php/product/73

 $1700.

 01-04 Sub WRX - $2395.

https://www.stillen.com/brakepros_detail.asp?id=32348&main=1

 Regards,

 Jim





Posted By: boxmaker85
Date Posted: October 08, 2004 at 1:51 PM
Cross drilled are good brakes but w/ a drawback (on some, not all brakes are like this but there are quite a few out there).  Cross drilled are exactly that they are drilled across the rotor.  Meanin that there are parts of the brake now missing.  This will sometimes weaken the structure of the rotor when you use the break and cause it to crack.  Look into the rotor and check the actual history of the type of rotor to see how it holds up in real life.




Posted By: supradude
Date Posted: October 09, 2004 at 3:46 PM
Yes, you can balance them with no problem. And alignment shouldn't be a problem either. One thing that I didn't notice anyone commenting on is the OFFSET. Make sure you get the correct offset, or they will sit under the vehicle too far, or sit out past the fender wells. If you get a good tire, they will last. Most companies try to push the cheapest tire they can if you buy the tire & wheel package. Hope this helps. Lewis

-------------
'85 Toy





Print Page | Close Window