Me laugh? Never - except that I still have an open window for my reply to your previous post.... I was searching for an "all informative" fuse blowing graph that shows how a fuse takes
time to blow depending on overload magnitude/current. EG - typically might sit all day at 100% overload, maybe 0.001 seconds at 10,000% overload, and maybe seconds or minutes at 200% overload etc. IE - fuses lack the "accuracy" that some expect, and
designs are somewhat flexible .
Why? Oh yeah - inrush currents....
Anyhow, the search found something else which led to.... and then... and...
And that's the only reason I'll laugh in this thread!
Good - closed that reply and info discarded (but saved in case you're interested...)
And as a post-edit
after below comment, you're fine - use any fuse between 10A and 30A.
But below is more detail... Assumptions, conditions, and a GENERAL but all-inclusive lesson in protection....
Ok...
Your diagram looks fine.
(Excluding trivial but implicit "main switch" fused +12V and groundings etc. EG - #85 is ground is GND is chassis is body is engine is 0V is battery -ve is "a common connection" to everything and is un-fused and "where & how" is generally unimportant provided they are good connections (paint scraped off etc) and ground loops etc are not an issue. Good - legal disclaimer and stating the obvious has now been achieved... or has it?) Phew!
(Oh! And a "circuit line" is electrically the same "point" or connection anywhere along that line. EG - the "horseshoe loop" is the same as "connecting everything to #87". Conversely, all the monitor "#85's" mean any GND point. In practice, such interconnections are whatever is practical- eg, you probably would not have 4 monitor grounds all connected to the one #85 relay terminal....) Phew again?
Alas all
above may be obvious stuff with a bit of experience, but confusing to some - like
"can I move the top left monitor to under the bottom right monitor?". Electrically it is all the same - it has nothing to do with where or how etc.
Oh no... brace yourself...
(That assumes reasonable cabling and loads - ie, no undersized cables hence no voltage drops, ground loops etc) I'm now officially all Phew'd out.
Yay!
Oi - I heard that!
paperboi wrote:
Are you saying that the fuse on the battery should be 10A and not the rating of the wire? |
|
|
No. It
can be...
A 30A wire from the battery to the relay. Hence a fuse NO GREATER than 30A to protect the cable (from downstream faults).
But also everything between that fuse and the next downstream fuse must be 30A rated.
A 40A relay? Cool.
A 30A relay? Cool.
A 20A relay? Reduce "battery fuse" to 20A.
The fuse now protects the weaker of the downstream components.
Now, 10G from the relay (output).
Damn - what's 10G...?
$#%#@!! &*%%$**! ...&.. !!*&&*$#@!! A 4 meter return trip to bookshelf....
Aha! 12G is ~30A so 10G is above 30A (9G is 50A) - that's "my" source, but I never use those ratings anyhow. (Check -
powerstream.com/Wire_Size... 10G is 55A for chassis; 15A for transmission. Cool - don't hang it in the air 'cos that gets hot if you run a more than a
steady 15A load.
Great! So paperboi being the clever 12volter that he (else she) has done a brilliant job (IMHO). That's worth another PHEW! (Trust me - thank you!)
So assuming 30A cable and 30A or larger relay and 10G to the monitors, then a 30A fuse is fine at the battery.
Certainly no bigger fuse - it cannot exceed its smallest
downstream un-fused cable or device. (EG - hence if a 15A or 20A relay, reduce the fuse to 15A or 20A respectively.)
But we can use a smaller fuse - it just can't be BIGGER than downstream....
How small?
Not so small that it does not handle the load.
And it
should have at least 20%-30% "headroom" as a general ROT (Rule Of Thumb) that allows for hotter ambient temperatures (hence fuse and breaker deratings), minor overloads, etc.
So, what did we say... 4 monitors @ 0.75A each = 3A total.
Hence say a minimum fuse size of 5A?
Lets use 10A - extra margin and still WAY under our
distribution sizing. (I do like over-sized distribution - if cost and weight acceptable. It allows for later expansion; is more robust; with smaller voltage drops...)
Or maybe IF you have 15A fuses anyway, use 15A.
Thanks to your (say) 30A design, you have the flexibility of using
any fuse from 5A to 30A.
I'd suggest starting with 10A (if you have them; else 15A else 20A etc) and if that does not blow, then fine.
If smaller fuses blow (maybe due to inrush; maybe just because), increase the size.
Note that the
0.75A monitors may have a 1A or larger fuse.
It may be that 750mA fuses are rare. Or that 750mA "average" plus the 30% ROT means "rounded to" the common 1A fuse.
Or it may be a 2A fuse because - despite 1A being common and ROT'd for a 750mA average, they allow for inrush and other transients, or higher temperatures (especially in vehicle cabins!).
The point is that
arguably, the upstream fuse should not be LESS than the sum of the total monitor fuses - eg, if 2A, then 4x2A = 8A which means a 10A fuse (not 5A).
That argument would be based on all monitors having an "up to" 2A inrush, hence an "up to" 8A inrush is logical.
Or it may be based on statistical crap where random peaks MIGHT be up to 2A, hence theoretically a possible 8A even if statistically only one a year etc. (Hence one of many reasons that some fuses seem to randomly but rarely blow.)
But maybe it's a 2A fuse because they need a 1.1A fuse, and 2A is the next
practical size.
That
reality makes nearly a 50% change in our upstream fuse assumption - ie, 4x1.1A = 4.4A => a 5A fuse is fine.
That's an example of using equipment fuse ratings for
dimensioning purposes.
Add up all the fuses in your domestic loads and you probably get 10 times the value of your main fuse etc.
Same for the fuses in your car as opposed to the main fuses (fuselinks aka flinks) - although they are (sub-) distribution fuses rather than
equipment fuses.
Whilst fuses may indicate the maximum current a load may take (eg, 110% of rating longterm, 200% for 10 seconds) and hence max power input (ditto times input voltage) and hence max power output (ditto less inefficiency), it does NOT indicate typical power. EG - I have seen amplifiers that quote RMS output powers based on stated voltage and hence running at 100% efficiency at greater than 110% fuse ratings! That's possible, but man those fuses will get hot....
Smaller is better to limit sparks or short-energy and relay contact damage etc.
Larger is better for robustness against surge gremlins.
And probably I am too fussy - after all, 30A relays often handle more than 30A; fuses have minimum response times etc.
And we are not designing for a 20A or 30A load. Though it's a 30A distribution system, our load is only a few Amps...
We... er you - are only fusing to protect against short circuits - not a high current that will normally flow and hence pre-heat insulation and components....
Just remain practical - use a fuse that you already use, or is common and cheap etc.
The above is a classic case of "distribution fusing" or protection.
And therein ends this short reply.
But as to the monitor protection....