78mc-bbc wrote:
Oldspark, haha you told me to post this as a topic, so i did, LOL! |
|
|
Of course! I will never PM suggestions etc when it's a good "public" design project! (Never - absolutely never... LOL!) But I rarely "tell" someone to post as a new thread, I merely suggest (ha ha). (Talented people understand the merits of a public post anyway.)
But now I know
why the parallel relays. I thought it may have been for redundancy - even if there was an unseen switch for the spare. (As some old fart recently wrote: "
But if one fuse blows, why not the other?" etc etc. But that's ANOTHER design topic!)
I generally recommend against parallel relays & circuits to supply the
total needs of a (power source) supply. That can require measures to share the current (eg, series resistance).
Besides, if one leg fails, the other(s) then blow if they can't handle the load. (Viz many paralleled relay circuits I have seen, and my
former UPS - fun watching each individual unfused relays or power transistors/FETs take their turn to burn (ie - smoke, but that didn't rhyme with
turn). Even if fused, that's "all" fuses blown (ok if two cheapies, but when more, or bigger costly fuses...)
Instead IMO it's well worthwhile getting properly rated components.
I use a FRC6BC-1 which is 150A (~AUD$15;
SY4073 - Automotive Relay 150A SPDT) for my battery isolator. (Its NC 100A 87a is not used.)
But there should be similar elsewhere, and with mounting options missing from the FRC6BC-1.
But two other issues:
Topology: I'm with father Howie. Split into smaller legs etc.
Or rather, IMO, certain things warrant their own fuses (if not relays) - eg, ejection seats, nitrous, other
biggish loads.
Certain things suit a dedicated fuse panel - eg, gauges, warning lights, etc, though they often share a common fuse.
Some fuseboxes have twin feeds so you can split IGN & ACC or battery +12V, or split from different
master fuses for independence (eg, seats & nitrous separated gauges etc).
Dimensioning: If the loads are known, it is easier determining total power (current) requirements.
That typically has 2 outcomes - eg, assume total peak current or fusing of individual loads totals (say) 150A. But that is not a realistic scenario, hence we use might use a 100A relay and "master" fuse & wire (or I'd probably use
my 150A relay with 150A - 200A wire and a 100A fuse).
That meets the "max 125A" spec on the fusebox, and uses a more common (smaller) master fuse. (And if the relay & wire handle it, the fuse could be upgraded later.)
The 2nd dimensioning outcome is over-designing the supply anyhow. That's the same case as not knowing the total (future?) loads, and covered above - ie, despite only needing 125A (the max for the fusebox) or less for the loads, use an overrated supply distribution (especially cable, but also relay) but with suitable fusebox or load fuse (125A or 100A etc).
I usually over-design (over-size) the distribution so the fuses (or relays) can be upgraded later.
[ My battery isolator uses hefty cable - maybe 100A - 300A (one day I'll actually check!) despite its paltry 2.5A "normal load" requirement. But add the battery recharge current - typically well under 10A but can peak at ~45A - and my former 60A relay was fine. I'm now using the 150A relay for other reasons (testing etc). And I use 50A self-resetting circuit breakers at each end, 50A being the largest of it's kind - namely weatherproof & cheap ($7 each); a plastic version of Jaycar's
Chassis Mount 50A Autoreset Circuit Breaker.
]
Remember - a fuse must protect its downstream components (wires, relays, etc) UNTIL the next fuse takes over. But that does not mean that fuse cannot be smaller - it just has to be big enough to handle the load. [But never exceed its downstream distribution which in turn may be much bigger than its required Amperage. {yes - a paraphrased repeat of the above.}]
BTW - the alternative to an IGN switched relay is for all power to be off the battery, but the individual loads are relay or switch controlled. EG, IGN +12V supplies the switch for the gauges, or (the switch to) the relay's coil that turns on gauges, seats, nitrous. That's usually my topology, but it is a case of minimal relays versus circuit independence etc.
I also think of other outcomes, like:
- so much for another short comment or reply,
- see, I told you others would help!
- ... but I'm surprised there aren't more (responses from others),
- and no comments yet on the relay's 85 & 86 polarity!
Alas, breakfast coffee down, I'm out to adjust my toe-in. Can that defer my call to my GF to tell her when I'll be around...?
